Skip to main content

When an ism isn't an ism...

When I finished my undergrad degree I was faced with the age old question: what next? I had nothing lined up and the world was my oyster, so long as whatever it offered was exceptionally cheap. One option I considered was going on to do a masters in gender or LGBT studies - it being a particular interest of mine - but I eventually concluded it was a) beyond my means (I'd have to cough up for tuition, accommodation, and living expenses as South Wales lacked a course) and b) unlikely to help me get a full time job. Anyway, the point of this story is that Goldsmiths was one of the universities I looked into.

I'm glad that's as far as I got.

Goldsmiths Student Union is in the midst of a scandal at the moment after their diversity officer, Bahar Mustafa, used the official SU account to tweet #killallwhitemen and label other students 'white trash'. She says it was an in-joke and I'm sure it was, though it obviously speaks of problems within the SU of cliquey, unprofessional behaviour. Similarly the closed meeting for BME women and non-binary people has been blown out of proportion - safe spaces are important, particularly with initial organising meetings as I believe the one in question was.

Bahar Mustafa - petitions for and against her sacking are gaining signatures this week.

My real concern is the claim she made in her defending statement: "There have been charges laid against me that I am racist and sexist towards white men. I, an ethnic minority woman, cannot be racist or sexist towards white men, because racism and sexism describe structures of privilege based on race and gender. Therefore, women of colour and minority genders cannot be racist or sexist, since we do not stand to benefit from such a system."

Mustafa graduated from Goldsmiths with a MA in Gender, Media & Culture. The above really makes me question their standard of teaching. The idea that racism and sexism rely solely on the perpetrator being in a relative position of power is popular on the net, especially on Tumblr where such beliefs are seen as a prerequisite for SJW (Social Justice Warrior) status. Looking at racism specifically, this is an Americo-centric view which relies on the principle that BME individuals (or in US phraseology, POC: Persons of Color) are always a minority of the population, and white individuals always the majority. (Because presumably there is nothing but an unpopulated wasteland beyond the borders of the United States of America.)

The core problem of Tumblr style activism - the recognition that there are numerous factors which oppress (see intersectionality), but an obsession with the idea of 'checking your privilege' frequently leads to only more in-fighting and exclusionism.

Of course, the reality is rather different. It's perfectly possible for a white individual to experience racism in India, Japan, or Trinidad. Oh, and the UK, and the USA, and even Sweden. As a white British woman, let me assure you, I can be racist to a white Polish man - it doesn't matter that thanks to his gender he historically has more power than me (though it must get UKIP women like Diane James off the hook). Similarly, a black woman in the UK can be racist to a Roma woman, who in turn can be racist to a Chinese woman. It doesn't matter that all three are members of oppressed minorities in their country of residence. Even if you're not willing to relinquish the idea that racism requires power, you have to at least concede that the power balance shifts between every interaction making it difficult to make claims like 'all BME women can never be racist'.

The issue is that you can't just superimpose US experience on other places. In the US race is seen as the key determining factor when it comes to levels of attained education, income, and so on. In the UK it's class. The truth is that in both countries the experiences of being 'white' or 'black', or 'male' or 'female', or 'rich' or 'poor' are not homogeneous. A middle class white woman will have different experiences to a white woman living below the poverty line, though they have the commonality of being white and women. A black Muslim will face different challenges to a black Jew, though they share skin colour and perhaps any number of other descriptors, from 'short' to 'model train enthusiast'.

In the classic Monty Python sketch all three are white British men of a similar age - but socio-economic status makes all the difference.

It also completely ignores the legislative realities of the UK. As gov.uk sets out: "It is against the law to discriminate against anyone because of: age, being or becoming a transsexual person, being married or in a civil partnership, being pregnant or having a child, disability, race including colour, nationality, ethnic or national origin, religion, belief or lack of religion/belief, sex, or sexual orientation. These are called ‘protected characteristics’." This means that under UK law you can be - and people have been - convicted of racist behaviour for calling a Welsh person 'a sheep shagger' because it implies prejudice against their national origin. That example really illustrates the wide scope of the UK legal definition of 'racism'.

American media might be ubiquitous, but that doesn't mean to say all American beliefs, laws, and values apply the world over. Bahar Mustafa is guilty of nothing more than being naive and unprofessional - Goldsmiths itself is the one that ought to take a long hard look at what they're offering students for the hefty sums they're charging.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Free Magazine Scans

Click the pictures below to find full cover guides to various teen magazines (primarily collated to make scale miniature magazine covers but I figure they'll also be useful for collectors and anyone into media history) and scans from my own magazine collection. I've also got a couple of kids' books I didn't want to part with - The Squirrel and Little Owl Book of Pets . The unwieldy size of my bookmark folders convinced me I needed a reference post for online magazine archives. Or, more accurately, free online magazine archives. Whether you're looking for leisure reading or research avenues, you're bound to find something useful in this list. :) ☆ Archive for the Unexplained - UFO mags galore. ☆   The Magazine Rack - over 140,000 digitised magazines! ☆   Lantern - thousands of vintage film magazines. ☆ FANZINES  - a number of online archives now exist for these including  FANAC  (SF), ScoTpress  (Trek), Sandy Herald Collection  (media fandom, major

50 Free Welsh Language Resources

Unlike literacy and maths, Welsh really isn't a subject we'll be using everyday without a concerted effort to do so. Every morning we've been doing three Duolingo lessons with Marianna - challenging for me and repetition of basic words and concepts for her - and then watching a couple of Welsh language cartoons to listen to the rhythm of the words and so on. Here is a list of free Welsh language resources from around the web, ranging from GCSE revision guides to adult basics to children's cartoons uploaded to YouTube. Hopefully you'll be able to mix and match to suit your own needs over the next few weeks and months. (I'd normally direct people to places like Sain Wales to buy hard copy media, but they're closed for the duration and we should try to lighten the load on the postal service to essentials besides.) Apps . Handy rundown of Welsh language kids' apps from Montgomery Church in Wales School. Atebol . Welsh language story time on Yo

Simply Cook Review

I kept seeing ads and deals for Simply Cook everywhere, so as there was a special offer on at OhMyDosh! Rewards (£3 for the box and £3.50 cashback) I figured I had nothing to lose by giving it a try. What Is It? Recipe kits packed into boxes which fit through your letterbox. The usual price is £9.99 for a kit of 4, with each one serving 2-4 people depending on your serving sizes. All you need to do is buy the fresh ingredients required and follow the instructions. Here is Simply Cook's own helpful diagram: Does It Work? For me, as the person just eating it, it was awesome. Everything tasted great - the mushroom penne in particular was so good I went back for seconds - and I liked that the sauces weren't as rich as Anthony would usually make them. For Anthony, who cooked them, they weren't as impressive. He complained that the food was bland and that it was actually quite a lot of faff, as Lidl didn't stock everything we needed which meant another trip ou

Free Fabric Samples x 200

Choosing upholstery and soft furnishings can be a nightmare - especially if it arrives and isn't quite what you expected. Fabric samples are a great way to avoid costly mistakes, as well as providing a fab source of material for your crafts box. Here are over 200 places offering completely free fabric samples in the UK:

Welsh UFO Sightings 2016

Welsh UFO sightings from 2016. For sightings from other years please click HERE . UK UFO Sunday 3rd January, 01:25 Gwent Witness saw a 'typical space ship' through their bedroom window. It had blue and red lights, and appeared to be moving towards them. They watched for a few minutes and the next day reported the sighting to UK UFO. FM: " I was up really late and i needed to use the bathroom so i got up and my side of the bed is by the window, so i had a look out. i saw an object shaped like a typical space ship would look, but it had blue and red lights and appeared to be coming towards me. i watched it for a while and then left to use the bathroom and by the time i had returned (5 minutes later) the mysterious lights had almost disappeared into the distance. " SUFON Tuesday 5th January, 09:20 Bevan Close, Waunarlwydd, Swansea  Broken cloud. Brian Harry was at home in Bevan Close, Waunarlwydd and had just let his dog out the back