Skip to main content

RIP Arthur, May Your Memory Forever Live On

Arthur Labinjo-Hughes

I was 13 when I read A Child Called 'It', Dave Pelzer's memoir of the horrific child abuse inflicted by his mother in 1960s America. It had a huge impact on me then and remains one of those things that I almost wish I had never encountered because, frankly, it's the stuff of nightmares. This wasn't neglect or crisis induced violence. This was years and years of systemic mental and physical torture, with David singled out while the other children in the house lived a relatively normal life.

This meant that, though various individuals made reports before David was eventually put into foster care at the age of 12, they were largely dismissed by authorities because the house was well kept and the other children well cared for. His mother told people David was just a problem child she tried her best for and his brothers, afraid of becoming replacement targets, did all they could to back her up.

When informed of impending outside visits David's mother would clean him up and promise things would change. Feed him, and hug him, and get him to tell the visitors that there was nothing wrong at home. He would comply, sometimes through fear, sometimes through the simple joy of believing he had somehow convinced his mother to love him again. Then things would swiftly return to 'normal'.

As horrific as it was to read, that book had historical distance. It couldn't happen now, surely?

At the very least the professionals and agencies dealing with safeguarding would be sufficiently well trained not to have the wool so easily pulled over their eyes?

The details of what Arthur Labinjo-Hughes suffered in the last miserable months of his life broke me this week. His little voice crying out that nobody loved him as he struggled to stand will haunt me for the rest of my days, the actual film and audio footage carrying the immediacy that Dave Pelzer's descriptions of his mother forcing him to recite what a bad boy he was as she starved him never could have.

I cried for hours. I didn't sleep for days.

But what absolutely slaughtered me was a report in the Daily Mail that after Arthur's paternal grandparents got nowhere, his maternal grandparents tried again to report the abuse to social services and the police - they were told neither agency had any concern because the house was "immaculate".

Like they had never even encountered the idea it could be otherwise.

The issue here is that this wasn't a straightforward case of child neglect. This wasn't a kid being left to their own devices because the carers couldn't provide, whether because of mental/physical health issues, substance abuse, or any other reason. This was a case where the carers simply chose not to provide. To go out of their way to make Arthur suffer. To capture it all on surveillance camera so they could relive each and every moment.

And I get the calls for the return of the death penalty. For harsher sentences. But they can't help Arthur. They won't help other children in his situation either. If harsh punishments were truly a deterrent crime wouldn't have existed under the bloody code. If capital punishment was enough to have stopped this kind of abuse, Dave Pelzer should have been absolutely fine in California.

What can make a difference is the funding of public services and the training of the people who staff them.

Torfaen is kind of infamous for having the highest number of looked after children, per population head, in the entire country. As of April 2021 one in 44 children in the borough were in state care. Our poverty and deprivation figures aren't massively different to other authorities. National government says we just need to be less 'risk averse' and stop worrying about near misses, like the 2010 case of a three year old reduced to eating their own hair to survive after parents locked them in a filthy freezing room for days. It's a criticism I'll gladly shoulder as a TCBC councillor if it means at risk children have someone looking out for them.

But even with our high figures I worry every day about children falling through the cracks.

The size of social worker caseloads and the ongoing underfunding is the kind of thing that keeps me awake at nights. The kids deemed not to meet the care threshold - as if abuse never escalates - and the kids who fly under the radar when their abuser moves them out of area and they become another social services department's problem. The members of the public put off from reporting concerns by ridiculously over complicated council pages aimed at school teachers and children's services professionals - you really don't need the full MASH form and reminders about parental/guardian consent for referrals on your public facing social services contact page - and the constant narrative that children are solely the problem of their parents (think the recent school dinner debate) and if they can't or won't provide, well, that's just too bad then.

It shocks me that a boy like Arthur was apparently so unknown to Solihull children's services. There had been safeguarding issues around his birth mother's substance abuse and mental health, long before she ended up in prison, and one of Tustin's previous partners has also gone on the record about social services visits for her other children. Multiple reports were submitted from various family members as well as members of the local community - school and neighbours. If a MASH (Multi Agency Safeguarding Hub) is working correctly, it's difficult to see how this can happen.

But, then, it assumes that it is working. That there are enough staff and enough resources. That as many people as possible have basic safeguarding training, and that other members of staff know who to pass referrals on to.

Hanging Hughes and Tustin might make us feel better, but ensuring public services are running the way we want them to might actually save another child like Arthur.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Free Magazine Scans

Click the pictures below to find full cover guides to various teen magazines (primarily collated to make scale miniature magazine covers but I figure they'll also be useful for collectors and anyone into media history) and scans from my own magazine collection. I've also got a couple of kids' books I didn't want to part with - The Squirrel and Little Owl Book of Pets . The unwieldy size of my bookmark folders convinced me I needed a reference post for online magazine archives. Or, more accurately, free online magazine archives. Whether you're looking for leisure reading or research avenues, you're bound to find something useful in this list. :) ☆ Archive for the Unexplained - UFO mags galore. ☆   The Magazine Rack - over 140,000 digitised magazines! ☆   Lantern - thousands of vintage film magazines. ☆ FANZINES  - a number of online archives now exist for these including  FANAC  (SF), ScoTpress  (Trek), Sandy Herald Collection  (media fandom, major

Free Fabric Samples x 200

Choosing upholstery and soft furnishings can be a nightmare - especially if it arrives and isn't quite what you expected. Fabric samples are a great way to avoid costly mistakes, as well as providing a fab source of material for your crafts box. Here are over 200 places offering completely free fabric samples in the UK:

Guide to Sindy Houses

As far as 1/6 scale doll houses go, Sindy's Super Home is fairly ubiquitous. It's a good size, it isn't made out of pink plastic, and you can pick one up on eBay for under £50. But the Super Home wasn't Sindy's only foray into property ownership. In fact she had numerous different houses, caravans, stables, and other buildings... 1970 Sindy's Town House Though this was advertised in the 1970 brochure, it doesn't seem to have ever made it into production. 1973 Sindy's House This one apparently made it into limited production, but was flimsy and was soon replaced. According to the Sindy Museum , it had four rooms, decorated as a bedroom, bathroom, kitchen and lounge. You can see part of the house used for photos in the 1974 catalogue . 1974 Sindy's House Existing examples appear to have been competition wins, so it is unlikely this house was ever on general sale. You can read more about it HERE . 1975

Simply Cook Review

I kept seeing ads and deals for Simply Cook everywhere, so as there was a special offer on at OhMyDosh! Rewards (£3 for the box and £3.50 cashback) I figured I had nothing to lose by giving it a try. What Is It? Recipe kits packed into boxes which fit through your letterbox. The usual price is £9.99 for a kit of 4, with each one serving 2-4 people depending on your serving sizes. All you need to do is buy the fresh ingredients required and follow the instructions. Here is Simply Cook's own helpful diagram: Does It Work? For me, as the person just eating it, it was awesome. Everything tasted great - the mushroom penne in particular was so good I went back for seconds - and I liked that the sauces weren't as rich as Anthony would usually make them. For Anthony, who cooked them, they weren't as impressive. He complained that the food was bland and that it was actually quite a lot of faff, as Lidl didn't stock everything we needed which meant another trip ou

Welsh UFO Sightings 2016

Welsh UFO sightings from 2016. For sightings from other years please click HERE . UK UFO Sunday 3rd January, 01:25 Gwent Witness saw a 'typical space ship' through their bedroom window. It had blue and red lights, and appeared to be moving towards them. They watched for a few minutes and the next day reported the sighting to UK UFO. FM: " I was up really late and i needed to use the bathroom so i got up and my side of the bed is by the window, so i had a look out. i saw an object shaped like a typical space ship would look, but it had blue and red lights and appeared to be coming towards me. i watched it for a while and then left to use the bathroom and by the time i had returned (5 minutes later) the mysterious lights had almost disappeared into the distance. " SUFON Tuesday 5th January, 09:20 Bevan Close, Waunarlwydd, Swansea  Broken cloud. Brian Harry was at home in Bevan Close, Waunarlwydd and had just let his dog out the back